Tuesday, July 12, 2005 1:36 AM

 New Suit 2NT - Part II

 

Pitbulls:

 

          Lets enumerate how many times an invitational 2NT bid occurs as responder without biding a forcing 1NT first.  The humble 1♣ opener .  1♣-P-1♦-P  1♥-P-2NT or 1♣-P-1♦-P  1♠-P-2NT  or 1♣-P-1♥-P  1♠-P-2NT or  1♣-P-1♦-P   2♣-P-2NT or  1♣-P-1♥-P   2♣-P-2NT or  1♣-P-1♠-P   2♣-P-2NT

 

Next the 1♦ opener . 1♦-P-1♥-P  1♠-P-2NT or   1♦-P-1♥-P   2♦-P-2NT or  1♦-P-1♠-P   2♦-P-2NT  or 1♦-P-1♥-P   2♣-P-2NT or 1♦-P-1♠-P   2♣-P-2NT

 

Next the 1♥ opener    1♥-P-1♠-P 2♥-P-2NT   or  1♥-P-1♠-P  2♣-P-2NT   or  1♥-P-1♠-P  2♦-P-2NT 

 

What is a leap to 3NT ? Exactly 12-14 with a stopper in the unbid suit(s) ?. A rebid at the two level by opener in a new suit or otherwise can be as high as 17 HCP . The best game or slam begins to be investigated at the 4 level after partner essentially has pre-empted the auction by bidding 3NT. What about all the responders hands in these auctions that are greater than 14 HCP ? You now must bid a phony 3rd suit or 4th suit forcing which wrong sides the NT and gives no idea to partner about the strength or distribution of your hand ? 4th suit forcing detracts from natural bidding and adds arkwardness.

 

          Would it not be nice to have a 2NT as a game force unless opener relays to stay in a partial ? This leaves 4th suit forcing or 3rd suit forcing to be natural and exploratory. Right siding the 3NT or investigating slams starts at a lower level.

 

          You have 17 HCP and a 5-4-3-1 and open something that ends up partner leaping to 3NT ? Do you make a slam try ? Probably not as you are in the 30 HCP range. What if your singleton matches partners Jxxx  ot Axxx. You are cold for slam but did not even try to get there. You could be cold for 5 of a minor and in 3NT off 5 losers in a wide open suit . 4th suit forcing auctions are confusing. Would it not be nice if partner jumped to 3NT showing a strong NT opener and you leap to 6NT with your 16-17 HCP hand  knowing you have 33 HCP’s ?

 

          The 2NT as a “new suit” simplifies auctions. The relay allows us to escape in a partial and you can “pattern out” to show your distribution and strength. Lets try a few auctions :

 

1♥-P-1♠-P   2♦-P-?       J10xxx Qx AQxx AQ     In standard methods you must bid 3♣ 4th suit forcing or leap

to 3NT ?

 

Lets give opener x AKxxx KJ10x Kxx  and 6♦ is cold and impossible to reach. Give partner Q AKxxx KJ10x xxx and  she has an impossible bid over 3♣. 3NT with no club stopper and wrong siding the contract ? Try these hands with 2NT forcing and you can pattern out or right side the 3NT. Ugly things happen in these 4th suit auctions like rebidding 4 card suits or rebidding bad 5 card suits. There are no bids left as opener was forced into a corner.

 

I like playing a jump rebid as responder as “recovering the strong jump shift” and forcing with a good suit. Partner opens 1♦ and you respond 1♠ on AJ10xxx Jx xx Axx and partner rebids 2♦ . Rebidding 2♠ is a terrible underbid on a hand that was built for 3♠ invitational. Playing 2NT as a one round force allows you to use 3♣ as NMF for invitational hands ( similar to 2♦ after a 2♣ rebid) . Partner can not bid 3NT in these auctions as you did not bid 2NT forcing so an invitational sequence is coming up. Partner bids 3♥ or 3♦ and you bid 3♠ invitational. Similar auction after a 1♥-2♥ rebid auction with a 10 HCP spade hand.

 

You hold Axxx Kx xxxx AQx  and partner opens 1♦ . You bid 1♠ as you are all controls and partner bids 2♦ so now what ? A leap to 3NT or a phony 3♣ which wrong sides the 3NT and forces partner into a corner ? Would it not be better to bid 2NT and over partners bid support diamonds ? With an unsuitable hand partner can bail to 4NT and the NT is right sided. Partner hand is x Axxx AKxxxx xx and a grand slam in diamonds is on a hook ! Partner could hold many other hands where 3NT is the spot but right sided from the AQx of clubs side !

 

I think the 2NT concept as a “new suit” will pay dividends and gets rid of the ugly 4th suit forcing at the two level. Right siding 3NT contracts or getting to nice slams or minor suit games will garner a lot of IMPS. As Granoveter says the only thing you lose is playing in 2NT where exactly 2NT makes. We all know how many times that occurs in IMPS. The rest of our system is designed not to play in 2NT anyway so lets make it complete.