Thursday, August 17, 2006 12:49 AM

Hand Evaluation - 2/1 ( Modern garbage style )

PITBULLS:

The line that “Bridge is a game of suits” is attributable to the bidding genius Benito Garozzo . From my own experience , saying that he is correct is an understatement. One of my most significant systemic changes over the years is playing a 2/1 not forcing to game when the suit was rebid. This understanding was after a major opened so the forcing NT was cleansed to being more of a NT bid. This cured the disgusting habit of hiding 6 card suits with a forcing NT bid thereby never recovering later. Believe it or not this is a hand from a Spingold , the partnership was Rodwell & Meckstroth.

♠void ♥AQxxx ♦AJxxx ♣Kxx opposite ♠Jxx ♥K10 ♦xx ♣AQ109xx Rodwell opened 1♥ , Meckstroth hid his nice 6 card suit with a forcing NT. Rodwell rebid 2♦ & Meckstroth giving partner maximum leeway due to their “style” bid 2♥. Rodwell giving maximum leeway to Meckstroth due to his style , passed two hearts & that’s where they played it.

7♣ is a lucky make as the breaks were very favourable. What a difference if partner responds 2♣ non forcing to game instead of the hideous 1NT. 7♣ is probably not reachable but you get to 6♣ without breathing hard. This was during the 90’s where the Bridge World was in a constant battle with the “modern bidders” . These “modernists” had to bend over backwards all the time to give maximum leeway due to their horrendous opening bids & overcalls.

Here is a direct quote from Jeff Rubens of the Bridge World in discussing the leeway Meckstroth & Rodwell gave each other on this hand. “If you are one of those who enjoy sneering at modern bidding” , this last deal of the quarter is going to be worth the price of a year’s subscription , at least. ”

I personally hate “modern garbage bidding” with its undisciplined element & giving partner leeway all the time as it destroys the partnership element of the game of Bridge . This “leeway” relegates Bridge to single handed poker status. I feel “modern bidders” are getting Bridge & poker confused. One of the games is played single handed but not the other one.

Giving leeway to garbage bidders undermines constructive bidding. This is why you must make a choice when you buy into modern garbage bidding. Leeway is a synonym for distrust in the game of Bridge. Trust is tantamount to good partnership bidding. Giving up trust & discipline is just big a sacrifice to play a destructive style of Bridge unless you are a pro in weak fields.